{"schemaVersion":1,"baselineEdition":"ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a","extensionVersion":"ottoman-ministry-extension-8b250fab8a7eae45","personId":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","oldid":"0094_44; 85","coreInventoryMember":false,"presentationOnly":true,"source":{"id":"ministry-extension","label":"User-supplied cross-ministry personnel workbook","sha256":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","rows":7532,"calendar":{"field":"year","label":"AH source year","exactEventDate":false,"basis":"Same annual field as the prior personnel workbook; source personnel metadata labels year as Year, hicri. Every ordered source ID/year pair matches the prior workbook, and year minus dobirth equals age on all 7,532 rows.","birthYear":{"field":"dobirth","calendar":"AH","basis":"Same source arithmetic clock as annual year; original field retained."},"firstWorkYear":{"field":"firstjob_year","calendar":"unverified","rule":"New officials have no independently corroborated first-work calendar; no dated firstAppointment is constructed."}},"salary":{"field":"wage","interpretation":"assigned nominal monthly kuruş","basis":"same annual wage field as the prior personnel workbook; inherited edition unit contract","directWorkbookUnitLabel":false},"department":{"field":"hangimemur4","interpretation":"source classification label","hierarchicalMinistryVerification":"not_established"},"identifier":{"field":"id","interpretation":"literal archival reference copied as oldid in earlier workbook","numericMemurId":false,"referenceParsing":"not_inferred"},"calendarMetadata":{"filename":"october10.dta","sha256":"1db557601d727b4dbd05222b6a5fff19d055ad6764a953f7eb19023f144637e0","variableLabels":{"year":"Year, hicri","oldid":"Original individual ID","dobirth":"Year of birth","wage":"Wage (level)","firstjob_year":"First job year"}},"calendarArithmetic":{"completeRows":7532,"yearMinusBirthMinusAgeResiduals":[{"value":0,"rows":7532}]},"sourceVersion":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d","filename":"different_ministry.xlsx"},"counts":{"observations":2,"distinctYears":2,"hStart":1315,"hEnd":1316,"temporalRelations":{"new_person_source_career":2},"duplicateYearRows":0,"sameYearExistingRows":0},"observations":[{"id":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d:Sayfa1:3766","personId":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceVersion":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d","sourceSha256":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","sourceRow":3766,"sourceSheet":"Sayfa1","sourceCells":{"id":"Sayfa1!B3766","year":"Sayfa1!A3766","wage":"Sayfa1!D3766","currentjob":"Sayfa1!F3766","currentjob_place":"Sayfa1!H3766","currentjob_sehirkazanahiye":"Sayfa1!I3766","currentjob_vilayet":"Sayfa1!K3766","hangimemur4":"Sayfa1!DD3766","hangimemurnew":"Sayfa1!DC3766","position":"Sayfa1!DE3766","ptmemur":"Sayfa1!AG3766","currentjob_sancak":"Sayfa1!J3766"},"h":1315,"g":null,"calendar":"AH","salary":120,"title":"Nufus kalemi","originalTitle":"Nufus kalemi","place":"Kurucay","sourcePlaces":["Kurucay"],"secondaryPlace":"Kurucay","district":"erzincan","province":"erzurum","coordinatesRaw":"39.640110, 38.474309","placeId":"l-262792d61a0d686c","placeIds":["l-262792d61a0d686c"],"lat":39.64011,"lon":38.474309,"mapStatus":"agreed","institution":"Other","sourceGrouping":"Other","sourceGroup":"Other","institutionClassification":"literal_workbook_label","sourceGroupAlternative":null,"positionRaw":null,"ptmemurRaw":0,"paperIncluded":false,"temporalRelation":"new_person_source_career","simultaneousExistingObservationIds":[],"overlapComparisons":[],"duplicateSourcePersonYear":false,"salaryUnit":"nominal monthly kuruş","salaryUnitBasis":"inherited_personnel_source_contract","isMinistryExtension":true},{"id":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d:Sayfa1:3765","personId":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceVersion":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d","sourceSha256":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","sourceRow":3765,"sourceSheet":"Sayfa1","sourceCells":{"id":"Sayfa1!B3765","year":"Sayfa1!A3765","wage":"Sayfa1!D3765","currentjob":"Sayfa1!F3765","currentjob_place":"Sayfa1!H3765","currentjob_sehirkazanahiye":"Sayfa1!I3765","currentjob_vilayet":"Sayfa1!K3765","hangimemur4":"Sayfa1!DD3765","hangimemurnew":"Sayfa1!DC3765","position":"Sayfa1!DE3765","ptmemur":"Sayfa1!AG3765","currentjob_sancak":"Sayfa1!J3765"},"h":1316,"g":null,"calendar":"AH","salary":120,"title":"Nufus kalemi","originalTitle":"Nufus kalemi","place":"Kurucay","sourcePlaces":["Kurucay"],"secondaryPlace":"Kurucay","district":"erzincan","province":"erzurum","coordinatesRaw":"39.640110, 38.474309","placeId":"l-262792d61a0d686c","placeIds":["l-262792d61a0d686c"],"lat":39.64011,"lon":38.474309,"mapStatus":"agreed","institution":"Other","sourceGrouping":"Other","sourceGroup":"Other","institutionClassification":"literal_workbook_label","sourceGroupAlternative":null,"positionRaw":null,"ptmemurRaw":0,"paperIncluded":false,"temporalRelation":"new_person_source_career","simultaneousExistingObservationIds":[],"overlapComparisons":[],"duplicateSourcePersonYear":false,"salaryUnit":"nominal monthly kuruş","salaryUnitBasis":"inherited_personnel_source_contract","isMinistryExtension":true}],"newPerson":{"id":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","oldid":"0094_44; 85","aliases":["0094_44; 85"],"memurId":null,"name":"Mustafa Vehbi Efendi","named":true,"originallyNamed":true,"nameSource":"ministry-extension","nameAliases":["Mustafa Vehbi Efendi"],"olderOnly":false,"editions":["ottoman-ministry-extension-8b250fab8a7eae45"],"birthPlaceId":"l-5807a9c669912a04","birthPlaceIds":["l-5807a9c669912a04"],"birthPlace":"Kemah","birthProvince":"Erzurum","school":"Rusdiye Mektebi","route":"Unclassified","fatherJob":null,"languages":[{"language":"Turkish","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Arabic","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"French","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Persian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"English","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Italian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Armenian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Greek","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Rum","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Bulgarian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Russian","terms":[],"recorded":false}],"identity":{"birthH":1296,"religion":"Musluman","nationality":"Turkish","fatherJob":null},"preparation":{"school":"Rusdiye Mektebi","schoolingYears":7,"apprenticeshipYears":3,"qualification":null,"telegraphSchool":null,"languages":[{"language":"Turkish","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Arabic","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"French","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Persian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"English","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Italian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Armenian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Greek","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Rum","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Bulgarian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Russian","terms":[],"recorded":false}],"timingNote":"Schooling and apprenticeship numbers are source duration/classification fields. No dated education or training event is inferred."},"firstJobTitle":"Telgraf","firstAppointment":null,"supplementalFirstJob":{"title":"Telgraf","h":null,"g":null,"sourceYear":1312,"calendar":"unverified","salary":120,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CQ3765","Sayfa1!CQ3766","Sayfa1!CI3765","Sayfa1!CI3766","Sayfa1!CR3765","Sayfa1!CR3766"],"stableYear":true,"stableTitle":true,"explicitPttLabel":true,"interpretation":"Original first-work assertions; their year calendar and payment date are not independently verified."},"sourceLabelledPtAnchor":{"status":"unavailable","label":"Workbook-labelled PT start","interpretation":"unverified_first_work_calendar","h":null,"g":null,"calendar":"unverified","calendarBasis":"not_established","department":null,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceHash":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","evidence":[],"candidateYears":[],"reasons":["no_verified_post_telegraph_anchor"],"historicalVerification":"not_adjudicated","paidServiceVerification":"not_established"},"firstSalary":{"h":1315,"g":null,"salary":120,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","title":"Nufus kalemi","placeId":"l-262792d61a0d686c","observationId":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d:Sayfa1:3766"},"firstObservedTitle":"Nufus kalemi","coverage":{"observations":2,"hStart":1315,"hEnd":1316,"gStart":null,"gEnd":null,"gaps":[],"sourceEdition":"ottoman-ministry-extension-8b250fab8a7eae45"},"paperMembership":{"included":false,"observations":0},"conflictCount":0,"geographyUnresolved":false,"edition":"ottoman-ministry-extension-8b250fab8a7eae45","baseEdition":"ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a","observations":[{"id":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d:Sayfa1:3766","personId":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceVersion":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d","sourceSha256":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","sourceRow":3766,"sourceSheet":"Sayfa1","sourceCells":{"id":"Sayfa1!B3766","year":"Sayfa1!A3766","wage":"Sayfa1!D3766","currentjob":"Sayfa1!F3766","currentjob_place":"Sayfa1!H3766","currentjob_sehirkazanahiye":"Sayfa1!I3766","currentjob_vilayet":"Sayfa1!K3766","hangimemur4":"Sayfa1!DD3766","hangimemurnew":"Sayfa1!DC3766","position":"Sayfa1!DE3766","ptmemur":"Sayfa1!AG3766","currentjob_sancak":"Sayfa1!J3766"},"h":1315,"g":null,"calendar":"AH","salary":120,"title":"Nufus kalemi","originalTitle":"Nufus kalemi","place":"Kurucay","sourcePlaces":["Kurucay"],"secondaryPlace":"Kurucay","district":"erzincan","province":"erzurum","coordinatesRaw":"39.640110, 38.474309","placeId":"l-262792d61a0d686c","placeIds":["l-262792d61a0d686c"],"lat":39.64011,"lon":38.474309,"mapStatus":"agreed","institution":"Other","sourceGrouping":"Other","sourceGroup":"Other","institutionClassification":"literal_workbook_label","sourceGroupAlternative":null,"positionRaw":null,"ptmemurRaw":0,"paperIncluded":false,"temporalRelation":"new_person_source_career","simultaneousExistingObservationIds":[],"overlapComparisons":[],"duplicateSourcePersonYear":false,"salaryUnit":"nominal monthly kuruş","salaryUnitBasis":"inherited_personnel_source_contract","isMinistryExtension":true},{"id":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d:Sayfa1:3765","personId":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceVersion":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d","sourceSha256":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","sourceRow":3765,"sourceSheet":"Sayfa1","sourceCells":{"id":"Sayfa1!B3765","year":"Sayfa1!A3765","wage":"Sayfa1!D3765","currentjob":"Sayfa1!F3765","currentjob_place":"Sayfa1!H3765","currentjob_sehirkazanahiye":"Sayfa1!I3765","currentjob_vilayet":"Sayfa1!K3765","hangimemur4":"Sayfa1!DD3765","hangimemurnew":"Sayfa1!DC3765","position":"Sayfa1!DE3765","ptmemur":"Sayfa1!AG3765","currentjob_sancak":"Sayfa1!J3765"},"h":1316,"g":null,"calendar":"AH","salary":120,"title":"Nufus kalemi","originalTitle":"Nufus kalemi","place":"Kurucay","sourcePlaces":["Kurucay"],"secondaryPlace":"Kurucay","district":"erzincan","province":"erzurum","coordinatesRaw":"39.640110, 38.474309","placeId":"l-262792d61a0d686c","placeIds":["l-262792d61a0d686c"],"lat":39.64011,"lon":38.474309,"mapStatus":"agreed","institution":"Other","sourceGrouping":"Other","sourceGroup":"Other","institutionClassification":"literal_workbook_label","sourceGroupAlternative":null,"positionRaw":null,"ptmemurRaw":0,"paperIncluded":false,"temporalRelation":"new_person_source_career","simultaneousExistingObservationIds":[],"overlapComparisons":[],"duplicateSourcePersonYear":false,"salaryUnit":"nominal monthly kuruş","salaryUnitBasis":"inherited_personnel_source_contract","isMinistryExtension":true}],"events":[{"id":"p-927ba0fef93432d6:birth","kind":"birth","h":1296,"g":null,"label":"Recorded birth","placeId":"l-5807a9c669912a04","place":"Kemah","salary":null,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"dobirth"}],"assertions":[{"field":"name","value":"Mustafa Vehbi Efendi","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"name","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!C3765","Sayfa1!C3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"birthH","value":1296,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!R3765","Sayfa1!R3766"],"calendar":"AH"},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"Kemah","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"doplace","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!S3765","Sayfa1!S3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"nationality","value":"Turkish","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!W3765","Sayfa1!W3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"religion","value":"Musluman","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!X3765","Sayfa1!X3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"school","value":"Rusdiye Mektebi","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"education_level","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!Z3765","Sayfa1!Z3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":7,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!AA3765","Sayfa1!AA3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":3,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"mulazemetsuresi","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CK3765","Sayfa1!CK3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"firstWorkYearRaw","value":1312,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"firstjob_year","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CI3765","Sayfa1!CI3766"],"calendar":"unverified"},{"field":"firstJobTitle","value":"Telgraf","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"firstjob","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CQ3765","Sayfa1!CQ3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"firstJobSalary","value":120,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"firstjob_salary","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CR3765","Sayfa1!CR3766"],"calendar":null},{"field":"language:Turkish","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"ministry-extension","sourceField":"lang_turkish","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!AP3765","Sayfa1!AP3766"]}],"conflicts":[],"sourceRowsPath":"ministry-extension/source-rows/p-927ba0fef93432d6.json","citation":"Ottoman Bureaucracy, archival code 0094_44; 85, cross-ministry edition ottoman-ministry-extension-8b250fab8a7eae45, source workbook d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b.","presentationOnly":true,"coreInventoryMember":false,"institutionScope":"Source-classified cross-ministry careers","source":{"id":"ministry-extension","label":"User-supplied cross-ministry personnel workbook","sha256":"d6d8c6b0062dd86ccd5383ee739dfdbccd7bc8e1a5ff844b1b6fdca88e92d06b","rows":7532,"calendar":{"field":"year","label":"AH source year","exactEventDate":false,"basis":"Same annual field as the prior personnel workbook; source personnel metadata labels year as Year, hicri. Every ordered source ID/year pair matches the prior workbook, and year minus dobirth equals age on all 7,532 rows.","birthYear":{"field":"dobirth","calendar":"AH","basis":"Same source arithmetic clock as annual year; original field retained."},"firstWorkYear":{"field":"firstjob_year","calendar":"unverified","rule":"New officials have no independently corroborated first-work calendar; no dated firstAppointment is constructed."}},"salary":{"field":"wage","interpretation":"assigned nominal monthly kuruş","basis":"same annual wage field as the prior personnel workbook; inherited edition unit contract","directWorkbookUnitLabel":false},"department":{"field":"hangimemur4","interpretation":"source classification label","hierarchicalMinistryVerification":"not_established"},"identifier":{"field":"id","interpretation":"literal archival reference copied as oldid in earlier workbook","numericMemurId":false,"referenceParsing":"not_inferred"},"calendarMetadata":{"filename":"october10.dta","sha256":"1db557601d727b4dbd05222b6a5fff19d055ad6764a953f7eb19023f144637e0","variableLabels":{"year":"Year, hicri","oldid":"Original individual ID","dobirth":"Year of birth","wage":"Wage (level)","firstjob_year":"First job year"}},"calendarArithmetic":{"completeRows":7532,"yearMinusBirthMinusAgeResiduals":[{"value":0,"rows":7532}]},"sourceVersion":"different-ministry-d6d8c6b0062d","filename":"different_ministry.xlsx"},"additionalProfile":{"schemaVersion":1,"editionId":"ottoman-ministry-extension-8b250fab8a7eae45","personId":"p-927ba0fef93432d6","baseEdition":"ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a","sourceId":"ministry-extension","detailPath":"ministry-extension/profile/p-927ba0fef93432d6.json","assertions":[{"field":"rutbe","presentation":"unlabelled-code","assertions":[{"value":0,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"rutbe","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!DG3765","Sayfa1!DG3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Original copied source assertion; code meaning is not inferred."}]},{"field":"mecidinisani","presentation":"unlabelled-code","assertions":[{"value":0,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"mecidinisani","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!DH3765","Sayfa1!DH3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Original copied source assertion; code meaning is not inferred."}]},{"field":"nisanialiosmani","presentation":"unlabelled-code","assertions":[{"value":0,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"nisanialiosmani","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!DI3765","Sayfa1!DI3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Original copied source assertion; code meaning is not inferred."}]},{"field":"madalya","presentation":"unlabelled-code","assertions":[{"value":0,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"madalya","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!DJ3765","Sayfa1!DJ3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Original copied source assertion; code meaning is not inferred."}]},{"field":"firstjob","presentation":"recorded-text","assertions":[{"value":"Telgraf","sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"firstjob","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CQ3765","Sayfa1!CQ3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Original copied source assertion; code meaning is not inferred."}]},{"field":"firstjob_year","presentation":"recorded-text","assertions":[{"value":1312,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"firstjob_year","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CI3765","Sayfa1!CI3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"The first-work year value has no independently verified calendar for this new official. Associated annual years remain separate.","valueCalendar":"unverified"}]},{"field":"firstjob_salary","presentation":"recorded-text","assertions":[{"value":120,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"firstjob_salary","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!CR3765","Sayfa1!CR3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Independent first-salary field. Its payment date is not established by the first-work year."}]}],"death":{"statusAssertions":[]},"criminal":{"statusAssertions":[],"noteAssertions":[],"codeAssertions":[{"value":0,"sourceId":"ministry-extension","column":"adlisicilkaydi","sourceRows":[3765,3766],"sourceCells":["Sayfa1!DL3765","Sayfa1!DL3766"],"years":[1315,1316],"yearCalendar":"AH","note":"Raw legal-record code. Its meaning is unverified; zero does not establish a clean lifetime record.","kind":"unlabelled-code"}]}}},"profilePath":"ministry-extension/profile/p-927ba0fef93432d6.json","sourceRowsPath":"ministry-extension/source-rows/p-927ba0fef93432d6.json","backgroundConflicts":[]}