{"id":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","oldid":"58- 0110;213","aliases":["58- 0110;213"],"memurId":4224,"name":"Ali Muhtar Efendi","named":true,"originallyNamed":true,"nameSource":"september","nameAliases":["Ali Muhtar Efendi"],"firstJobTitle":null,"supplementalFirstJob":null,"sourceLabelledPtAnchor":{"status":"unavailable","label":"Workbook-labelled PT start","interpretation":"workbook_labelled_first_work","h":null,"g":null,"calendar":"AH","calendarBasis":"agreement_with_inherited_AH_fields","department":null,"sourceId":"supplemental","sourceHash":"5d62e80233900f904a72ff9729b6a210a2c182fbb275c1742236e2f254a2f607","evidence":[],"candidateYears":[],"reasons":["missing_workbook_department","missing_workbook_year"],"historicalVerification":"not_adjudicated","paidServiceVerification":"not_established"},"olderOnly":false,"editions":["older","september","recovered"],"birthPlaceId":"l-116680c790e0e606","birthPlaceIds":["l-116680c790e0e606"],"birthPlace":"beysehir","birthProvince":"konya","school":"Sibyan Mektebi","route":"Low","fatherJob":null,"languages":[{"language":"Turkish","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Arabic","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"French","terms":["Tekellum"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Persian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"English","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Italian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Armenian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Greek","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Rum","terms":["Tekellum"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Bulgarian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Russian","terms":[],"recorded":false}],"preparation":{"school":"Sibyan Mektebi","schoolingYears":4,"apprenticeshipYears":0.5,"qualification":1,"telegraphSchool":0,"languages":[{"language":"Turkish","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Arabic","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"French","terms":["Tekellum"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Persian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"English","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Italian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Armenian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Greek","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Rum","terms":["Tekellum"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Bulgarian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Russian","terms":[],"recorded":false}],"timingNote":"Schooling years are a duration/classification, not an acquisition date. Education and training dates await source-linked structured records; no dates are inferred here."},"firstAppointment":{"h":1284,"g":1867,"placeId":"l-31f769672acf6ec8","placeIds":["l-31f769672acf6ec8"],"place":"istanbul","salary":400,"salaryInterpretation":"Independent inherited first-salary field; the recorded first-work year/place do not themselves date this payment.","sourceId":"recovered","interpretation":"Recorded first-work fields can concern apprenticeship, paid instruction or earlier state service; they do not universally date a first Post and Telegraph appointment.","datePairs":[{"h":1284,"g":1867,"sourceId":"recovered","hField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","gField":"firstjobyear","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]}],"dateConflict":false,"dateNote":"Hijri/Gregorian labels co-occur in the recorded source row; no conversion is inferred."},"firstSalary":{"h":1284,"g":1867,"salary":400,"observationId":"recovered:48632","sourceId":"recovered","title":"Muhabere Memuru","placeId":"l-116680c790e0e606"},"firstObservedTitle":"Muhabere Memuru","coverage":{"observations":22,"hStart":1284,"hEnd":1306,"gStart":1867,"gEnd":1889,"gaps":[{"after":1297,"before":1299,"missingYears":1}],"sourceEdition":"recovered"},"paperMembership":{"included":true,"observations":19},"conflictCount":1,"geographyUnresolved":false,"edition":"ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a","identity":{"birthH":1264,"religion":"Musluman","nationality":"Turkish","fatherJob":null},"observations":[{"id":"recovered:48632","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48632,"h":1284,"g":1867,"salary":400,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-116680c790e0e606","placeIds":["l-116680c790e0e606"],"place":"beysehir","sourcePlaces":["beysehir"],"province":"konya","lat":37.67983,"lon":31.72481,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:48633","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48633,"h":1285,"g":1868,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:48634","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48634,"h":1286,"g":1869,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:48635","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48635,"h":1287,"g":1870,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48636","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48636,"h":1288,"g":1871,"salary":570,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48637","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48637,"h":1289,"g":1872,"salary":570,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48638","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48638,"h":1290,"g":1873,"salary":570,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48639","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48639,"h":1291,"g":1874,"salary":570,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48640","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48640,"h":1292,"g":1875,"salary":570,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-3931fd0430f3c297","placeIds":["l-3931fd0430f3c297"],"place":"turhal","sourcePlaces":["turhal"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.386956,"lon":36.084106,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48641","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48641,"h":1293,"g":1876,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-f1375f02d2c9138f","placeIds":["l-f1375f02d2c9138f"],"place":"erbaa","sourcePlaces":["erbaa"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.672632,"lon":36.572555,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48642","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48642,"h":1294,"g":1877,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-f1375f02d2c9138f","placeIds":["l-f1375f02d2c9138f"],"place":"erbaa","sourcePlaces":["erbaa"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.672632,"lon":36.572555,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48643","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48643,"h":1295,"g":1878,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-f1375f02d2c9138f","placeIds":["l-f1375f02d2c9138f"],"place":"erbaa","sourcePlaces":["erbaa"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.672632,"lon":36.572555,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48644","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48644,"h":1296,"g":1879,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-f1375f02d2c9138f","placeIds":["l-f1375f02d2c9138f"],"place":"erbaa","sourcePlaces":["erbaa"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.672632,"lon":36.572555,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48645","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48645,"h":1297,"g":1880,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-f1375f02d2c9138f","placeIds":["l-f1375f02d2c9138f"],"place":"erbaa","sourcePlaces":["erbaa"],"province":"sivas","lat":40.672632,"lon":36.572555,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48646","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48646,"h":1299,"g":1882,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48647","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48647,"h":1300,"g":1883,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48648","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48648,"h":1301,"g":1884,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48649","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48649,"h":1302,"g":1885,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48650","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48650,"h":1303,"g":1886,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48651","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48651,"h":1304,"g":1887,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48652","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48652,"h":1305,"g":1888,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:48653","personId":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":48653,"h":1306,"g":1889,"salary":600,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-8a302e6e03ec03bf","placeIds":["l-8a302e6e03ec03bf"],"place":"manastir","sourcePlaces":["manastir"],"province":"manastir","lat":41.03219,"lon":21.333862,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true}],"events":[{"id":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d:birth","kind":"birth","h":1264,"g":null,"label":"Recorded birth year","placeId":"l-116680c790e0e606","place":"beysehir","salary":null,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"dobirth"},{"id":"p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d:first-work","kind":"first-work","h":1284,"g":1867,"label":"Recorded first-work anchor","placeId":"l-31f769672acf6ec8","place":"istanbul","salary":null,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","dateConflict":false,"dateNote":"Hijri/Gregorian labels co-occur in the recorded source row; no conversion is inferred."}],"assertions":[{"field":"birthH","value":1264,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"beysehir","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"birthplace","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"beysehir","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"birth_place","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"birthProvince","value":"konya","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"birth_vilayet","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"school","value":"Sibyan Mektebi","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"school_year","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":0.5,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"mulazemet","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"qualification","value":1,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"derivedQualificationFlag","value":0,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"has_qualification","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"telegraphSchool","value":0,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"telgraf","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"religion","value":"Musluman","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"nationality","value":"Turkish","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"firstWorkH","value":1284,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"firstWorkG","value":1867,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjobyear","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"istanbul","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"firstWorkSalary","value":400,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjob_wage","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"birthLatitude","value":37.67983000000002,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"lat_birth_place","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"birthLongitude","value":31.72481000000001,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"lon_birth_place","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"name","value":"Ali Muhtar Efendi ","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"İsim","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"birthH","value":1264,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"beysehir","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"birthplace","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"birthProvince","value":"konya","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"birth_vilayet","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"school","value":"sibyan mektebi","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":0.5,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"mulazemet","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":0.5,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"MülazemetSüresi","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"telegraphSchool","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"telegraph_school","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"religion","value":"musluman","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"nationality","value":"turkish","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"firstWorkH","value":1284,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"firstjob_year","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"istanbul","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"firstWorkSalary","value":400,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"firstjob_wage","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"birthLatitude","value":37.67983000000002,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lat_birth_place","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"birthLongitude","value":31.72481000000001,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lon_birth_place","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"language:Turkish","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_turkish","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Turkish","value":3,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_turkish2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Arabic","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_arabic2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"language:French","value":"Tekellum","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_french","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:French","value":1,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_french2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Persian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_persian2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:English","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_english2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Italian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_italian2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Armenian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_armenian2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Greek","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_greek2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"language:Rum","value":"Tekellum","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_rum","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Rum","value":1,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_rum2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Bulgarian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_bulgarian2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Russian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_russian2","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"name","value":"Ali Muhtar Efendi ","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"İsim","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"birthH","value":1264,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"beysehir","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"birthplace","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"birthProvince","value":"konya","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"birth_vilayet","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"school","value":"sibyan mektebi","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":".5","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"MülazemetSüresi","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"telegraphSchool","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"telgraph_school","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"religion","value":"musluman","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"nationality","value":"turkish","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"firstWorkH","value":1284,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"firstjob_year","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"istanbul","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"firstWorkSalary","value":400,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"firstjob_wage","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"birthLatitude","value":37.67983000000002,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lat_birth_place","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"birthLongitude","value":31.72481000000001,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lon_birth_place","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"language:Turkish","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_turkish","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Turkish","value":3,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_turkish2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Arabic","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_arabic2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"language:French","value":"Tekellum","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_french","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:French","value":1,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_french2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Persian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_persian2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:English","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_english2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Italian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_italian2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Armenian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_armenian2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Greek","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_greek2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"language:Rum","value":"Tekellum","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_rum","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Rum","value":1,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_rum2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Bulgarian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_bulgarian2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Russian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_russian2","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]}],"conflicts":[{"field":"qualification","values":[{"field":"qualification","value":1,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[48632,48633,48634,48635,48636,48637,48638,48639,48640,48641,48642,48643,48644,48645,48646,48647,48648,48649,48650,48651,48652,48653]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[56938,56939,56940,56941,56942,56943,56944,56945,56946,56947,56948,56949,56950,56951,56952,56953,56954,56955,56956,56957,56958,56959]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[4669,4670,4671,4672,4673,4674,4676,4677,4678,4679,4682,4687,4688,4689,4690,4691,4692,4695,4697,4699,4702,4703,4704]}],"resolution":"All stored assertions retained. Names prefer September, then older; supplemental names fill only missing names. Other preferred attributes use recovered, then September, then older, with modal nonblank value and source-order tie break. This does not adjudicate historical truth or changes in coding."}],"sourceRowsPath":"source-rows/p-01c3aa3a5db2d39d.json","citation":"Ottoman Bureaucracy, archival code 58- 0110;213, website data edition ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a."}