{"id":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","oldid":"58- 202;397","aliases":["58- 202;397"],"memurId":4301,"name":"Besim Efendi","named":true,"originallyNamed":true,"nameSource":"september","nameAliases":["Besim Efendi"],"firstJobTitle":null,"supplementalFirstJob":null,"sourceLabelledPtAnchor":{"status":"unavailable","label":"Workbook-labelled PT start","interpretation":"workbook_labelled_first_work","h":null,"g":null,"calendar":"AH","calendarBasis":"agreement_with_inherited_AH_fields","department":null,"sourceId":"supplemental","sourceHash":"5d62e80233900f904a72ff9729b6a210a2c182fbb275c1742236e2f254a2f607","evidence":[],"candidateYears":[],"reasons":["missing_workbook_department","missing_workbook_year"],"historicalVerification":"not_adjudicated","paidServiceVerification":"not_established"},"olderOnly":false,"editions":["older","september","recovered"],"birthPlaceId":"l-02f43e460b43bef7","birthPlaceIds":["l-02f43e460b43bef7"],"birthPlace":"hayfa","birthProvince":"beyrut","school":"Mektebi Mahsusa","route":"Low","fatherJob":null,"languages":[{"language":"Turkish","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Arabic","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"French","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Persian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"English","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Italian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Armenian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Greek","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Rum","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Bulgarian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Russian","terms":[],"recorded":false}],"preparation":{"school":"Mektebi Mahsusa","schoolingYears":4,"apprenticeshipYears":0,"qualification":1,"telegraphSchool":0,"languages":[{"language":"Turkish","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Arabic","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"French","terms":["Kitabet"],"recorded":true},{"language":"Persian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"English","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Italian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Armenian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Greek","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Rum","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Bulgarian","terms":[],"recorded":false},{"language":"Russian","terms":[],"recorded":false}],"timingNote":"Schooling years are a duration/classification, not an acquisition date. Education and training dates await source-linked structured records; no dates are inferred here."},"firstAppointment":{"h":1300,"g":1883,"placeId":"l-02f43e460b43bef7","placeIds":["l-02f43e460b43bef7"],"place":"Hayfa","salary":500,"salaryInterpretation":"Independent inherited first-salary field; the recorded first-work year/place do not themselves date this payment.","sourceId":"recovered","interpretation":"Recorded first-work fields can concern apprenticeship, paid instruction or earlier state service; they do not universally date a first Post and Telegraph appointment.","datePairs":[{"h":1300,"g":1883,"sourceId":"recovered","hField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","gField":"firstjobyear","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"h":1300,"g":null,"sourceId":"recovered","hField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","gField":"firstjobyear","sourceRows":[50185,50186,50187,50188]}],"dateConflict":false,"dateNote":"Hijri/Gregorian labels co-occur in the recorded source row; no conversion is inferred."},"firstSalary":{"h":1300,"g":1883,"salary":500,"observationId":"recovered:50161","sourceId":"recovered","title":"Muhaberati Ecnebiye Memuriyeti","placeId":"l-02f43e460b43bef7"},"firstObservedTitle":"Muhaberati Ecnebiye Memuriyeti","coverage":{"observations":28,"hStart":1300,"hEnd":1329,"gStart":1883,"gEnd":1907,"gaps":[{"after":1300,"before":1303,"missingYears":2}],"sourceEdition":"recovered"},"paperMembership":{"included":true,"observations":22},"conflictCount":1,"geographyUnresolved":true,"edition":"ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a","identity":{"birthH":1281,"religion":"Hristiyan","nationality":"Rum","fatherJob":null},"observations":[{"id":"recovered:50161","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50161,"h":1300,"g":1883,"salary":500,"title":"Muhaberati Ecnebiye Memuriyeti","originalTitle":"muhaberati ecnebiye memuriyeti","placeId":"l-02f43e460b43bef7","placeIds":["l-02f43e460b43bef7"],"place":"hayfa","sourcePlaces":["hayfa"],"province":"beyrut","lat":32.794971,"lon":34.993812,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50162","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50162,"h":1303,"g":1886,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-98956156833b5e8a","placeIds":["l-98956156833b5e8a"],"place":"sevakin","sourcePlaces":["sevakin"],"province":"hicaz","lat":19.105576,"lon":37.331128,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50163","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50163,"h":1304,"g":1887,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-98956156833b5e8a","placeIds":["l-98956156833b5e8a"],"place":"sevakin","sourcePlaces":["sevakin"],"province":"hicaz","lat":19.105576,"lon":37.331128,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50164","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50164,"h":1305,"g":1888,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-98956156833b5e8a","placeIds":["l-98956156833b5e8a"],"place":"sevakin","sourcePlaces":["sevakin"],"province":"hicaz","lat":19.105576,"lon":37.331128,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50165","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50165,"h":1306,"g":1889,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-98956156833b5e8a","placeIds":["l-98956156833b5e8a"],"place":"sevakin","sourcePlaces":["sevakin"],"province":"hicaz","lat":19.105576,"lon":37.331128,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50166","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50166,"h":1307,"g":1890,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-b1745326627b3805","placeIds":["l-b1745326627b3805"],"place":"murefte","sourcePlaces":["murefte"],"province":"edirne","lat":40.669085,"lon":27.241429,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50167","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50167,"h":1308,"g":1891,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-b1745326627b3805","placeIds":["l-b1745326627b3805"],"place":"murefte","sourcePlaces":["murefte"],"province":"edirne","lat":40.669085,"lon":27.241429,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50168","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50168,"h":1309,"g":1892,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-b1745326627b3805","placeIds":["l-b1745326627b3805"],"place":"murefte","sourcePlaces":["murefte"],"province":"edirne","lat":40.669085,"lon":27.241429,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50169","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50169,"h":1310,"g":1892,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"Muhabere Memuru","placeId":"l-f3698e3490018159","placeIds":["l-f3698e3490018159"],"place":"izmir","sourcePlaces":["izmir"],"province":"aydin","lat":null,"lon":null,"mapStatus":"unavailable","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50170","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50170,"h":1311,"g":1893,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50171","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50171,"h":1312,"g":1894,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50172","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50172,"h":1313,"g":1895,"salary":500,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50173","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50173,"h":1314,"g":1896,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50174","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50174,"h":1315,"g":1897,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50175","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50175,"h":1316,"g":1898,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50176","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50176,"h":1317,"g":1899,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50177","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50177,"h":1318,"g":1900,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50178","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50178,"h":1319,"g":1901,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50179","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50179,"h":1320,"g":1902,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50180","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50180,"h":1321,"g":1903,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50181","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50181,"h":1322,"g":1904,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50182","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50182,"h":1323,"g":1905,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":true},{"id":"recovered:50183","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50183,"h":1324,"g":1906,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:50184","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50184,"h":1325,"g":1907,"salary":432,"title":"Muhabere Memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:50185","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50185,"h":1326,"g":null,"salary":432,"title":"muhabere memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:50186","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50186,"h":1327,"g":null,"salary":600,"title":"3. mudur","originalTitle":"3. mudur","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:50187","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50187,"h":1328,"g":null,"salary":800,"title":"muhabere memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-20b43df9daee1008","placeIds":["l-20b43df9daee1008"],"place":"canakkale","sourcePlaces":["canakkale"],"province":"biga","lat":40.147302,"lon":26.409895,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false},{"id":"recovered:50188","personId":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2","sourceId":"recovered","sourceRow":50188,"h":1329,"g":null,"salary":800,"title":"muhabere memuru","originalTitle":"muhabere memuru","placeId":"l-f3698e3490018159","placeIds":["l-f3698e3490018159"],"place":"izmir","sourcePlaces":["izmir"],"province":"aydin","lat":38.431183,"lon":27.173581,"mapStatus":"agreed","paperIncluded":false}],"events":[{"id":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2:birth","kind":"birth","h":1281,"g":null,"label":"Recorded birth year","placeId":"l-02f43e460b43bef7","place":"hayfa","salary":null,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"dobirth"},{"id":"p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2:first-work","kind":"first-work","h":1300,"g":1883,"label":"Recorded first-work anchor","placeId":"l-02f43e460b43bef7","place":"Hayfa","salary":null,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","dateConflict":false,"dateNote":"Hijri/Gregorian labels co-occur in the recorded source row; no conversion is inferred."}],"assertions":[{"field":"birthH","value":1281,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"birthplace","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"birth_place","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"birthProvince","value":"beyrut","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"birth_vilayet","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"school","value":"Mektebi Mahsusa","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"school","value":"mektebi mahsusa","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"school_year","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":0,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"mulazemet","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"qualification","value":1,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"derivedQualificationFlag","value":0,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"has_qualification","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"telegraphSchool","value":0,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"telgraf","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"religion","value":"Hristiyan","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"religion","value":"hristiyan","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"nationality","value":"Rum","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"nationality","value":"rum","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"firstWorkH","value":1300,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"ilk_ise_baslangic_yili","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"firstWorkG","value":1883,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjobyear","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"Hayfa","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"firstWorkSalary","value":500,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"firstjob_wage","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"birthLatitude","value":32.79497100000002,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"lat_birth_place","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"birthLongitude","value":34.99381199999999,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"lon_birth_place","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184,50185,50186,50187,50188]},{"field":"name","value":"Besim Efendi ","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"İsim","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"birthH","value":1281,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"birthplace","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"birthProvince","value":"beyrut","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"birth_vilayet","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"school","value":"mektebi mahsusa","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"mulazemet","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"MülazemetSüresi","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"telegraphSchool","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"telegraph_school","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"religion","value":"hristiyan","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"nationality","value":"rum","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"firstWorkH","value":1300,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"firstjob_year","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"firstWorkSalary","value":500,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"firstjob_wage","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"birthLatitude","value":32.79497100000002,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lat_birth_place","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"birthLongitude","value":34.99381199999999,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lon_birth_place","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"language:Turkish","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_turkish","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Turkish","value":3,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_turkish2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Arabic","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_arabic2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"language:French","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_french","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:French","value":2,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_french2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Persian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_persian2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:English","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_english2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Italian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_italian2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Armenian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_armenian2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Greek","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_greek2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Rum","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_rum2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Bulgarian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_bulgarian2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Russian","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"lang_russian2","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"name","value":"Besim Efendi ","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"İsim","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"birthH","value":1281,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"dobirth","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"birthPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"birthplace","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"birthProvince","value":"beyrut","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"birth_vilayet","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"school","value":"mektebi mahsusa","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"school_type","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"schoolingYears","value":4,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"education_year","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"apprenticeshipYears","value":"0","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"MülazemetSüresi","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"telegraphSchool","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"telgraph_school","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"religion","value":"hristiyan","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"religion","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"nationality","value":"rum","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"nationality","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"firstWorkH","value":1300,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"firstjob_year","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"firstWorkPlace","value":"hayfa","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"firstjob_place","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"firstWorkSalary","value":500,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"firstjob_wage","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"birthLatitude","value":32.79497100000002,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lat_birth_place","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"birthLongitude","value":34.99381199999999,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lon_birth_place","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"language:Turkish","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_turkish","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Turkish","value":3,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_turkish2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Arabic","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_arabic2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"language:French","value":"Kitabet","sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_french","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:French","value":2,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_french2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Persian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_persian2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:English","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_english2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Italian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_italian2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Armenian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_armenian2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Greek","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_greek2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Rum","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_rum2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Bulgarian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_bulgarian2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]},{"field":"derivedLanguageCode:Russian","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"lang_russian2","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]}],"conflicts":[{"field":"qualification","values":[{"field":"qualification","value":1,"sourceId":"recovered","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[50161,50162,50163,50164,50165,50166,50167,50168,50169,50170,50171,50172,50173,50174,50175,50176,50177,50178,50179,50180,50181,50182,50183,50184]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"september","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[58474,58475,58476,58477,58478,58479,58480,58481,58482,58483,58484,58485,58486,58487,58488,58489,58490,58491,58492,58493,58494,58495,58496,58497,58498,58499,58500,58501]},{"field":"qualification","value":0,"sourceId":"older","sourceField":"qualification","sourceRows":[45558,45559,45560,45564,45569,45572,45573,45574,45577,45581,45583,45584,45586,45587,45588,45593,45594,45595,45596,45598,45599,45604,45608,45609,45610,45613,45617,45618,45620,45622]}],"resolution":"All stored assertions retained. Names prefer September, then older; supplemental names fill only missing names. Other preferred attributes use recovered, then September, then older, with modal nonblank value and source-order tie break. This does not adjudicate historical truth or changes in coding."}],"sourceRowsPath":"source-rows/p-a3c2ba7dd6cee4d2.json","citation":"Ottoman Bureaucracy, archival code 58- 202;397, website data edition ottoman-bureaucracy-2026-10-11-v1-84d4f7f2230a."}